Plato's objections to the freedom of expression and artistic liberty.

 This blog is part of a task of 'bridge course' given by Dr Dilip Barad sir on subject:.

 To what extent do you agree with Plato's objection to the freedom of expression and artistic liberty enjoyed by creative writers? Identify texts (novels, plays, poems, movies, TV soaps, etc.) that can be justifiably objected to and banned based on Plato's objections. that can be justifiably objected to and banned based on Plato's objections. 

Question:

Why plato objected on freedom of expression and artistic liberty? 

Plato was concerned about freedom of expression and artistic liberty primarily because of his views on the potential impact of art and literature on society. In his works, especially in "The Republic," he argued that many forms of art and literature could be detrimental to moral and intellectual development. 

What are the main root causes of his objections?? 

1) Moral Corruption 

Plato believed that art particularly poetry and drama could influence people in negative ways also by depicting immoral behaviour which could lead human beings especially youth  to adopt harmful behaviour or attitude. 

2) Moral and psychological Impact

Plato believed that art has power to shape individual's character and morals. 

3) Emotional influence

Plato was also concerned that art could evoke strong emotions that might lead people away from rational thoughts and philosophical reflection. 

4) Education and censorship

Plato believed that education should have power to shape individuals to be virtuous and rational. In his view control of artistic content was a means to ensure that education and culture support the development of virtuous and rational citizens. 

 Some texts and movies that can be justifiably objected to and banned based on Plato's objections. 

1) play =Tughlaq

The play wich portraits the complexities of 14th century Sultan Muhammed Bin Tughlaq's reign touches on the themes of political idealism and governance. 

Plato might critique it for potentially promoting  a skeptical view of leadership and authority. 

2) Midnight Children by Salman Rushdie. 

This seminal novel blends medical realism with historical and political commentary. 

Plato might critique its blending of reality and fantasy for potentially misleading readers and distorting historical truths. 

3) The God of Small Things by Arundhati Roy

Roys novel deals with themes of forbidden of love, social discrimination, and family secrets. Plato might object for its depiction of taboos subjects and the way it challenges traditional social norms and values. 

TV show like 'Game of Thrones'

Such show know for its graphic violence, sexual content, and morally ambitious characters. This series might be seen as promoting immoral behaviour and undermining rationality. 

Movie like "Natural Born Killers"

This film directed by Oliver Stone, portrays violence and sensationalism in a way that Plato might argue could negatively influence viewer's behaviour and perceptions. 

Conclusion: I believe that art and literature has much impact on human beings . I also believe that harsh reality of society should be depicted through literature  and art but in such manner that it should not have negative impact on society. Creative Writers should depict/put the reality or history of society to it's people but in way that it should not have negative influence.